once it pertains to buying cheese at the grocery store, a block the cheddar seems favor a an easy enough ask, right? A fast stroll previous the dairy aisle cheese instance quickly suggests otherwise, though. Cheddar is not simply cheddar — there room a surprising variety of options. And also if deciphering every the state on those brand feels kinda confusing, trust me the you space not alone.

You are watching: Difference between mild and medium cheddar

I’m here to answer the questions you have and decode those brand on your choice of grocery save cheddar, therefore you can buy simply the right cheese because that you.

simply for now, forget all those cheddars you’ve checked out at trader Joe’s; that cheese situation is its own beast. In this guide, we’re concentrating ~ above the cheddars you’d discover at your local grocery store.

It’s true! once it pertains to cheddar, shade is not actually one indicator that taste. Cheddar cheese is naturally white come pale yellow in color, and also those dark yellow blocks and bags (which actually look orange!) room the an outcome of coloring. Annatto is the additive the most frequently used to offer naturally white cheddar a deep yellow-orange hint.

Aging is the procedure that influence the odor of cheddar. The much longer a cheese is aged, the an ext pronounced and sharp that flavor. This is what distinguishes gentle cheddar (typically age for simply a couple months, with a smooth, not too unique taste) from more flavorful, pronounced spicy cheddar (aged approximately a year or longer).

One type of aged cheddar us love is Alpine. You’re most most likely to view it marketed as a block from well-known cheesemaker Cabot. It’s a nutty, sharp-tasting, lactose-free cheddar with a taste the just might remind girlfriend of Swiss or Parmesan, and a texture prefer the latter. Alpine is a an excellent option for cheese boards, or any time you want something a small fancier 보다 your regular sharp cheddar.

Pro tip: You’re most likely to find aged cheddar marketed in blocks, no pre-shredded bags. Cabot is a reputable grocery keep brand through a few options of aged cheddar obtainable by the brick. Expect it to have actually a pronounced, sharp taste and, relying on the age, even a couple of of those savory crystals usually uncovered in Parmesan.


No matter what form of cheddar friend buy, friend will check out it labeling with one of these 4 classifications. Castle an indicator that the lot of time the cheese to be aged, i beg your pardon affects the as whole taste and texture the the cheese. Cheddar establishes a much more distinct and also sharp flavor and contains a reduced moisture contents the much longer it’s aged. Specific timing different from brand to brand, but mild cheddar is aged because that the shortest amount of time and also extra-sharp the longest.

Mild cheddar: Aged for the shortest amount of time, gentle cheddar has actually a creamy, subtle taste with a relatively high moisture content, i m sorry lends a smooth texture that doesn’t crumble easily. It’s straightforward to slice, and melts extremely well. Medium cheddar: aged slightly longer than mild cheddar, it’s a little an ext flavorful, although it lacks the distinctive bite of sharp cheddar. It’s additionally very great for melting and slicing. Sharp cheddar: A lengthier aging process leaves this cheese v a distinct and prominent flavor. It has a reduced moisture content, and while it does melt well it requires an ext heat to carry out so. Extra-sharp cheddar: The most assertive flavor amongst these classifications, v a really pronounced, spicy taste, and also likely to crumble or break as soon as sliced. Extra-sharp cheddar is finest for eating out of hand.

What come buy: for eating cheddar as is, go v the range that tastes finest to you. The an ext aged the cheese is, the less moisture that contains and also the more heat is required to melt it. So once it comes to cooking, mild, tool ,and sharp cheddars are best for melting, while extra-sharp and aged cheddars don’t melt together well.


The Cheddar Cheese Taste Test: us Tried 8 Brands and also Here’s Our favourite (Image credit: Kelli Foster)

two other usual labels you’re most likely to point out in the cheese instance are brand-new York-style cheddar and Vermont cheddar. In spite of their proximity, these two Northeast next-door neighbors offer two distinct styles that cheese. Brand-new York-style cheddar is known for its lengthy aging, which method it comes with a very prominent, extra-sharp taste, that’s often defined as pungent and bitter. Unlike timeless extra-sharp cheddar, it commonly has a texture comparable to soft cheddar.

Vermont-style cheddar, on the other hand, has nothing to carry out with the sharpness the the cheese or even where it to be produced. Instead, this label just refers come white, naturally colored cheddar, produced in Vermont and elsewhere.


while there space not rather as many options as buying block of cheddar, you’re likely to uncover bags of pre-shredded cheddar that room mild, sharp, yellow, white, or a mixture of cheeses. These bags are convenient, although contempt pricier than buying an equal amount the block cheddar. The shredded version also contains additive that prevent the cheese indigenous clumping with each other in the bag, which also way it doesn’t melt rather the same as fresh grated cheese.

See more: What Did Broderick Crawford Die Of Death, Broderick Crawford

What to buy: i will always recommend a block of grated cheese end the pre-shredded stuff. But if you desire convenience, pre-shredded cheddar will gain the task done.

Kelli Foster

Food Editor, plan & Prep

Kelli is the Food Editor for setup & Prep contents for Kitchn. She"s a graduate the the French cook Institute and also author of the cookbooks, Plant-Based Buddha Bowls, The Probiotic Kitchen, Buddha Bowls, and Everyday Freekeh Meals. She stays in new Jersey.