*

*
Some label it as historical romance; while rather argue that it no have all of the compelled elements, thus making it simply an historical novel- yet all would certainly agree that the 1936 work by Margaret Mitchell is just one of the quintessential works of American literature.

You are watching: Gone with the wind book banned

Gone with the Wind garnered the Pulitzer Prize because that Fiction in 1937 and also its 1939 film adaptation has gone into legendary cinema condition after win eight competitive and two honorary awards in 1940.

However, together one has pertained to expect from instant and beloved classics, both the novel and its big-screen equivalent have to be steeped in dispute from the start.

The film has been attributed for triggering numerous of the alters to the means Blacks are depicted on film, but has additionally been accused of historical revisionism and also criticized for glorification the slavery. Despite the criticism, and also after several re-releases transparent the 20th century, the story has end up being rooted in popular society where it has been heavily referenced, parodied, and analyzed. Changed for inflation, it is the many successful film in box-office history and, in 1989, was selected come be preserved by the nationwide Film Registry.

The criticism the Gone through the Wind concerning its portrayal the Blacks in the 19th-century south is exemplified in exactly how former field hands throughout the beforehand days of repair were defined in part 4, chapter 37, together “behaving as creatures of tiny intelligence might naturally be supposed to do. Like primates or tiny children turned loosened among treasured objects whose value is beyond their comprehension, lock ran wild- either from perverse pleasure in destruction or simply since of their ignorance.”

Mitchell also downplayed the violent function of the Ku Klux Klan.

Bestselling writer Pat Conroy, in his preface for the novel, explained Mitchell’s portrayal of the Klan as having actually “the very same romanticized role it had in The bear of a Nation and also appears to it is in a benign mix of the Elks Club and also a men’s equestrian society.”

However, chronicler Richard N. Present defends any type of historical inaccuracies when he pointed out that while Gone through the Wind perpetuates plenty of myths around Reconstruction- an especially with respect come Blacks- Mitchell did no originate them and the young novelist might hardly be faulted because that not discovering what the majority of experienced historians didn’t recognize themselves until countless years later.

Mitchell, herself, replied to a leader in 1937 that she had actually spent “ten year of analysis thousands the books, documents, letters, diaries, old newspapers, and also interviewing people who had lived with those devastating times” in preparation for composing her very first draft.

This is sustained in a very detailed 1991 biography of Mitchell (“Southern Daughter” by Darden Asbury Pyron). The author, a historian at Florida international University, created that, “She spent a large amount of time verifying historic facts. The fear of missing something or acquiring something dorn drove her to distraction.”

One of the many infamous and also judged scene is what the legislation and society of this particular day would define as “marital rape.” The scene begins with Scarlett and Rhett in ~ the bottom that the staircase; he starts to kiss her, refusing to be told ‘no’ through the struggling Scarlett. Rhett overpowers she resistance and carries she up the stairs come the bedroom, where the audience is left with tiny doubt what taken place next. The following scene reflects Scarlett the adhering to morning, aglow through barely-suppressed sexual satisfaction and Rhett apologizes because that his actions by blaming that on his drinking. The scene combines romance and rape in such a way that lock are tantamount from every other and also reinforces one of the many malicious myths around forced sex- that women secretly enjoy it, and that that is an acceptable way for a male to law his wife.

Molly Haskell has suggested that, nevertheless, ladies are mostly complacent of the scene and that it is constant with what women have actually in mind as soon as they fantasize around being raped- wherein their fantasies revolve approximately love and romance quite than compelled sex. Lock assume the Scarlett was not an unwilling sexual partner and also wanted Rhett come take together initiative.

So below we room with Gone through the Wind finding itself at number 26 on the American Library Association’s perform of the 100 most-banned classics.

Some of the much more notable incidents include when the brand-new York society for the Suppression of evil objected come Scarlett being married more than once; the Watch and also Ward culture in Boston check to fan the flames the dissent, wanting to get world upset end the prominence of Belle Ward (a madam) in the novel, but publication sellers to be making method too lot money to treatment what censors to be saying.

The federal government of the previous USSR prohibition Gone through the Wind because that 65 years. A Russian translation, by Tatiana Kudriavtseva, was finally published in Russia in 2001. In a CNN interview, she says, “The entirety thing occurred in Russia…we to be survivors the war, choose Scarlett, and this novel was ringing a lot of bells because that us. We witnessed the ravages, we experienced the fires, we saw the pilloried villages, and also we witnessed the poverty and the hunger… Gone with the Wind is taken into consideration in Russia as American War and also Peace.”

From that is publication, many about the United says took issue with lot of the language in the novel, especially the usage of indigenous such together “damn” and “whore.” Today, opposition has actually shifted from the profane come the social, through distain end the use of the word “nigger” in this and other standard novels.

Perhaps the most notorious incident regarding the language was when Rhett uttered that well known line in the movie, “Frankly, mine dear, i don’t provide a damn.”

Moviegoers staged a fixed exodus at various screenings across the country upon hear the word, insulted by its use. Media censors comment by raise a fine versus the studio for the incident; for this reason it was surprising to numerous that the would win anything at the 13th Academy Awards, permit alone Best photo and Director.

It was banned from the Anaheim, California Union High school District’s English classrooms in 1978, according to the Anaheim an additional Teachers Association, for its depiction of the habits of Scarlett O’Hara and the freed servants in the novel.

It was likewise challenged in the Waukegan, Illinois college District in 1984 since of the novel’s above-mentioned usage of the word “nigger.”

Again, here we are with a novel depicting a fictionalized set of civilization amid accurate historical events and the societal attitudes linked with not just the referenced period, but additionally the time in which it to be written and published. Today’s see of profanity may have actually changed, but the dead of enslavement coupled with existing politically-correct ignorance space once more being encountered not by maturation discussion and also knowledgeable discourse, however by banning books and burying heads in the sands that time.

There proceeds to be this pandemic of parents and also other self-righteous people who believe that they- and they alone- must shelter anyone from the realities of background and have actually the pure authority to carry out so.

The most important thing about history, though, is the it is a mirror of not just our past; yet of ours present and also our future. Us must recognize the mistakes of the past if we are to have actually an enlightened and complimentary society walk forward. We have actually a duty and a require to recognize that together behavior and atrocity did take place so that we can learn what we have overcome and how much we have to go.

So when people, for any type of reason, desire to throw out publications that lock disagree through or space offended by it leaves me v a very annoyed and defiant disposition. Their ignorance offends me, however that doesn’t typical I need to attempt to half their appropriate to your opinion. Ns encourage them to describe in mature dialogue your reasoning.

See more: New England Patriots Are Located Where, New England Patriots Team History

To the book burners; to those that hide native the fact of history; to those that oppress the end of ignorance and fear I have the right to only say this: Frankly, my dear, i don’t provide a damn.

For an ext information ~ above the Banned publications Awareness and Reading for expertise project and also the finish list of title covered, please visit the main website at http://smashville247.net/