Is there anything wrong through an eight year old re-reading the same books over and over again? The publication doctor thinks not, but additionally offers some tempting alternatives


Zachary Gordon and Robert Capron in a scene from Diary that a Wimpy Kid: Dog Days. Is there any harm in re-reading the publications endlessly? Photograph: Diyah Pera/AP
Zachary Gordon and also Robert Capron in a scene from Diary of a Wimpy Kid: Dog Days. Is there any kind of harm in re-reading the publications endlessly? Photograph: Diyah Pera/AP
My eight-year-old son’ s independent reading has taken turn off by virtue (or not) of the diaries that the wimpy kid. That is now re-reading them because that the third time. I have tried the latest David Williams book, and also classics favor The Lion, the Witch and the Wardrobe however they have all been rejected for another re-read of Greg’s adventures. I desire to maintain the attention in books and reading alone that has actually been kindled by these books which it seems to be ~ adored by children, less so through parents. I additionally want him to stretch his vocabulary. Deserve to you recommend any kind of books which monitor on unique from this collection so the the live independence reading might continue and progress?

Many parental share your frustration as soon as they clock a child show up to acquire “stuck” on an author. Come an observer, there is other depressing around the same book being read time and also time again. From the outside, it looks prefer there is no range and no progress for the reader and it is therefore easy come think the the son would be having actually a an ext interesting analysis experience if only they could move ~ above a brand-new book. And also it seems logical to think so. After ~ all, a brand-new book supplies interesting new characters and also any number of new adventures. However there is many of research right into re-reading that mirrors that that has great benefits because that toddlers – mental how regularly you may have had actually to review the exact same bedtime story? - and also for adults. So, the chances are the it is a good thing because that eight year olds too.

There are evident reasons why re-reading is fun – and babies and also toddlers present it night after night when they hear the same story. Their pleasure as they anticipate what they understand is walking to take place next is palpable. The is a pleasure that only comes from re–reading. Teachers, too, favour re-reading as a way of encouraging children to engage an ext deeply with a book and to think about the language and also style the it. In her monitorings of youngsters as reader in The reader in the Writer, Myra Barrs support re-reading on the grounds that periodically there might be as well much meaning in a story for a reader to grasp it completely on their very first reading that it. She also points the end that children, favor all various other readers, carry something of themselves to the publications they read and also that may change during re-readings in ways that might be illuminating. Few of the reasons why children like re-reading include: reading is easier when you are acquainted with the plot and characters and also that helps the analysis process; readers may get more out the a story on succeeding re-readings since they room not having to think around the brand-new things; re-reading allows for the possibility to savour the language and also experience; re-reading gives more space because that the leader to engage at a personal level.

All that may seem a rather weighty justification because that re-reading Jeff Kinney’s number of volumes that The Diary that a Wimpy Kid however the ethics behind re-reading are in general great and might serve your kid well when he does move on. And also maybe re-reading is a part of childhood that need to be celebrated. In an post in the new York Times, Verlyn Klinkenborg wrote, “Childhood is an oasis of repeated acts, so lot so that there is miscellaneous shocking around the first time a young leader reads a publication only once and then moves on come the next. There’s a hunger in that act but likewise a type of forsaking, a glimpse of adulthood come come.”

To help your boy make that transition there are numerous authors writing what is currently termed center grade fiction. The success of David Walliams and also Jeff Kinney in details shows just exactly how enthusiastic eight come 10 year olds have the right to be around reading – once they have actually the best book. Straightforward transition would certainly be to move onto Liz Pichon’s Tom Gates, the eponymous hero the The Brilliant world of Tom Gates and also its numerous sequels which, like The Diary the a Wimpy Kid, room told in words and pictures. Andy Stanton’s she a bad Man, mr Gum i m sorry is richly depicted by David Tazzyman, is additionally the an initial of a handful of titles about an outrageous character and the daft things he it s okay up to, all told in a richly inventive language. Horatio Clare’s Aubery and also the destructive Yoot is a remarkable yarn in i beg your pardon the ebullient Aubrey have to break a terrible spell that has been cast over his father even though everyone claims it will be difficult to do. Hamish, star the Danny Wallace’s Hamish and also the never ever People, is another little size hero v a few extra skills to assist him. And there room many modern-day classics for the age group too. These incorporate Roald Dahl’s Charlie and the cacao Factory, James and also the giant Peach and also Danny the Champion that the World every one of which space richly imaginative adventures. Michael Morpurgo, best known for battle Horse, speak wonderful stories of all kinds including the wonder The Butterfly Lion and more straightforward adventures such together Kensuke’s Kingdom. Any kind of of these would certainly be great for your son to check out – and to re-read too.

You are watching: What age group is diary of a wimpy kid for

Got any more an excellent books to recommend for a Diary of a Wimpy boy addict? Tell us on Twitter and also we’ll include your concepts to this blog. You have the right to use the very same email address to ask the book Doctor a publications related question.

Your ideas

Great answer come non-problem. Additionally suggest graphic novels of series like Percy Jackson + 13-Storey Treehouse books. Https://

— EmilyGale (
GdnChildrensBks A young reader I know has really enjoyed Timmy fail by Stephan Pastis, very sharp and funny and rather choose Wimpy Kid.

See more: How Do You Spell Massage Therapist Definition And Meaning In English

— Gregory Evans (

Jodie: mine 7 year old boy who has his nose in a publication constantly, for sure loves the Captain Underpants books by Dav Pilkey and also the wimpy boy books. I quite choose them too!

Jessie: I have a pointer for a child who loves Diary the a Wimpy Kid. The Aldo Zelnick series by Karla Oceanak. It’s comparable to Diary the a Wimpy boy in the it’s in a “journal” like form and has portrayed pictures in ~ (although the illustrations are much more detailed), and one that the objectives of the publication is come teach vocabulary. I’ve suggested them come a couple of of the patrons who come right into the library wherein I work, and also they like that there is less potty humour.