The tempt of the evil Presidency does no seem diminished, even for those that initially collection their sights higher.

You are watching: What does it mean that the vice president is only a heartbeat away from the presidency

Vice chairman Alben Barkley describes the 1948 version of the angry President"s seal to prime Minister Ali khan of Pakistan and his wife. Truman Library

A couple of months ago, President lindon Johnson was mirroring Prime Minister Lester Pearson that Canada the handsome chandelier which, many thanks to Mrs. Kennedy, again hangs in the treaty Room the the White House. He described where it had remained in the meantime: ”… when President Theodore Roosevelt would need to open the home windows in the evening to permit the breeze in to store cool … the chandelier would certainly tinkle and also keep that awake. For this reason he called the servant one evening to gain the chandelier the end of here and take it down to the Capitol. The frustrated servant said, ‘Where carry out we take it it?’ he said, ‘Take it to the angry President, he needs something to store him awake.’”

The story is the newest repetition of the legend that the Vice president is generally a Throttlebottom that “sits around in the parks and also feeds the pigeons, and takes walks and also goes to the movies.” This classic formulation that the evil President’s role broke right into the national consciousness in 1931 in the glittering music comedy the Thee i Sing . But the idea had long smouldered close come the surface—possibly indigenous the day john Adams, the first man to hold the office, lamented that he had actually not “the smallest degree of power to carry out any great either in the executive, legislative, justice departments. A just Doge the Venice … a just mechanical tool to wind increase the clock.” the did not aid either john Adams or the reputation of the office that in make the efforts out assorted titles because that the primary officials that the new government, councilor Maclay that Pennsylvania had mischievously dubbed Adams “His Rotundity.” yet the angry President, together Adams observed quickly, was invested v “two different powers—the one in esse and also the various other in posse.” In esse he was nothing. Adams when complained the he to be forbidden come speak in the Senate, end which that presided, also on topics he could throw irradiate upon. Yet in posse he might be everything. And also the potential of walk in a trice from nothing to every little thing has constituted fundamentally the fascination of the office.

From the outset the nature of the vice Presidency was blurry. In ~ the constitution Convention, Elbridge Gerry of Massachusetts, that was self destined to host the office under James Madison, saw no require for having actually a Vice president at all, especially due to the fact that his single duty would be come preside end the Senate. Gerry insisted that “the close intimacy that must subsist in between the President and Vice President makes absolutely improper.”

Whether jealousy or not, the Vice chairman inevitably would nourish one appetite because that the problem of power not vouchsafed to him in the Constitution. And for strong men—and your wives—the feeling of inferiority can be keen. Adams’ beloved Abigail readily available him no uncertain advice once it was believed he would be Jefferson’s runner-up: “Resign, retire. I would be second … to no man however Washington.” Nevertheless, for patient men, confident that their turn at the helm would certainly come in early time, there might be contentment and grace in accepting a function of insignificance. As it turned out, it was Jefferson who became Adams’ evil President, and as the Virginian collection out because that Philadelphia at an early stage in 1797 to i think the 2nd Office, he composed to his lifelong friend, James Madison, “I shall escape right into the city as secretly as possible. If governor Mifflin need to show any kind of symptoms of ceremony, pray contrive to parry them.” The very same sensitivity, however, was soon forcing Jefferson to complain the no one to be consulting with him “as to any type of measures the the government”—despite Adams’ opinion that him as “the an initial prince the the country, and also the heir obvious to the can be fried authority.”

The conception of the evil President as the assured “next-in-line” ended with Aaron Burr. Burr had actually tied v Jefferson in the Electoral college balloting for the Presidency in 1801 and would no accept without a hit the second place—for which, it to be understood, the votes because that him had actually been cast. The residence of Representatives, now referred to as upon to select a President, called Jefferson. Burr thereupon ended up being Vice President, because that the initial Constitution had detailed that “after the an option of the President, the Person having actually the greatest number of Votes the the Electors shall be the vice President.” to his credit Burr perform his official functions with éclat. “One that the finest officers that ever before presided end a deliberative assembly,” one senator called him. Yet Burr’s failure to productivity willingly to Jefferson, his strange connivance through the Federalists in 1801 and also 1804, and also his dastardly duty as Hamilton’s slayer, all merged to do him political poison for Jefferson the 2nd time around. ~ Burr ceded his farewell resolve to the Senate on in march 2, 1805, it to be reported, “he lower from his chair, and also in a dignified path walked to the door, which resounded as he with some pressure shut the after him. … There was a solemn and silent weeping for perhaps five minutes.”

The slammed door and the spontaneous shedding that tears, despite real, were additionally symbolic: one era in the brief background of the angry Presidency had come to a close and what complied with was a reason for sorrow. So late in 1804, the Twelfth Amendment had been included to the Constitution, making it crucial thenceforth for the presidential electors to note their ballots to show separately their choices for President and Vice President. Never again would there be a disgrace favor the electoral challenge of 1800–1801. Yet a new kind of degradation was now possible: the evil Presidency can be offered as an inglorious prop to “shore up” a nationwide ticket.

Almost immediately, George Clinton of brand-new York became the an initial Throttlebottom, selected due to the fact that he came from crucial northern state and also was a spokesman for every little thing still remained of Antifederalist sentiment. A perennial candidate for either the Presidency or vice Presidency due to the fact that 1788, Clinton ended up being in 1805 the second of Jefferson’s vice Presidents. Senator william Plumer of new Hampshire speak warmly the Clinton’s an individual charm and dignity, also writing, “He shows up honest.” but Plumer had actually other words, too: “He is old, feeble & completely uncapable of the duty the presiding in the Senate. He has actually no mind —no intellect—no memory—He forgets the question, mistakes it— not infrequently declares a vote before it’s taken—& often forgets to do it after the is taken— takes up brand-new business while a inquiry is depending.” despite at the sheet of senility, Clinton, ~ a powerful effort to win the Presidency, to be re-elected Vice chairman on the ticket headed by James Madison in 1808. The qualities that had actually made that a an excellent “balance” on the Jefferson ticket made that a perfect enhance to the dad of the Constitution, together well.

See more: Why Did They Call John Kennedy Jack, Why Did People Sometimes Call John F

This pairing that the qualities of President and Vice President, started so long ago, came to be more marked as the public progressively participated in presidential politics. Occasionally it seemed just the matching of personal qualities. Because that instance, Martin valve Buren’s to run mate in 1836 was Richard Mentor Johnson of Kentucky. Whereas valve Buren appreciated a reputation as a sophisticated, perfumed dandy, Johnson favored to boast: “I was born in a cane-brake and also cradled in a sap trough.” and also when the Republicans offered Calvin Coolidge a nomination in his own right in 1924, they chose as his ticket-mate Charles “Hell and Maria” Dawes—in part because his vigor and loquaciousness contrasted v the President’s taciturnity. (Dawes’ eloquent and profane testimony prior to the residence Committee on battle Expenditures had come to be a best seller in ~ the government Printing Office.)

Sometimes the pairing appeared to it is in based just on solitary issues. In 1876 once the Democrats determined Samuel J. Tilden of brand-new York, a sound-money man, they conveniently “neutralized” the by designating for the 2nd place cutting board A. Hendricks the Indiana, a wellknown inflationist. As soon as William Jennings Bryan the Nebraska to be nominated in 1896 on a free-silver ticket that showed up to smack the the stuff of revolution, the curse was diluted by picking for the angry Presidency Arthur Sewall that Maine, a financial institution president.

Age and geographical origins have been other components that ticket devices down with the years have sought come balance. In 1952, Richard Nixon’s youthfulness was vital factor in his gift selected to was standing alongside basic Eisenhower, the oldest significant party nominee in end a century. And was lyndon Johnson no being one “opposite” to john F. Kennedy when he confessed to a cheering Boston audience in 1960 that their agree of him had made “this nephew of a ‘federate soldier feeling lahk mah-ty tall cotton, let me tell you”?